Explain the difference between Multi channel music,
Super Audio CD and DVD Audio?
The CD has been the dominant music
format for many years now, but over the last three
years higher quality formats have been developed which
aim to give better quality music reproduction.
he ultimate goal is to achieve the
sound quality and open expressive sound produced by
vinyl without the associated spurious noise, but with
the convenience CD’s.
The new music formats DVD Audio
and SACD both utilise much high sampling rates than
CD and also offer far greater dynamic range and bandwidth.
This allows far greater frequency responses with improved
dynamics which produces a more realistic and natural
reproduction.
SACD and DVD Audio both also support
multi channel music mixes which are created to recreate
the ambience and effect of listen to the music live
at a concert. Both SACD and DVD Audio require specific
machines for playback but most manufactures now include
SACD and DVD Audio decoders in their DVD players.
In our experience the different
formats have different advantages to suit certain
applications:
DVD Audio is fantastic for live
multi channel concert performances when replayed through
a good quality surround amplifier. DVD quality video
playback combined with 5.1 digital sound quality truly
makes you feel like you’re at the concert.
SACD is far better suited to high
quality stereo reproduction where the huge sampling
rate and dynamic range result in a highly detailed
sound. The result is an extremely accurate and precise
reproduction, capturing all of the ambience and harmonics
of the original performance. The results from a top
quality SACD stereo system are breath taking and really
show the vast improvement over CD.
Most SACD discs now come with
both stereo and multi channel mixes but we have yet
to hear a multi channel recording that sounds anywhere
close to the stereo mix. We would highly recommend
leaving the multi channel side to DVD Audio.
Pros and Cons overview
| > Compact Disk (CD) |
|
Pros |
Cons |
> Industry standard
> Best value for money |
> Does not support multi channel
> Sampling rate of 128bit is not the best
reproduction available |
| > Super Audio Compact
Disk (SACD) |
|
Pros |
Cons |
> Much higher sampling rate
than CD
> Suited to high quality stereo where the
huge sampling rate and dynamic range result
in a highly detailled sound
|
> More expensive
> Require specific machines for playback
> Multi channel SACD is nowhere near the
quality of SACD stereo.
|
| > DVD Audio |
|
Pros |
Cons |
> Much higher sampling rate
than CD
> Best for multi channel music (e.g. concerts)
> Most DVD players now support SACD and DVD
audio
|
> More Expensive
> Require specific machines for playback
|
|