|
Plasma, LCD or Projector?
No doubt at some point you
will have told that plasma TV’s are poor quality
and LCD screens are superior or that high quality
projectors are only available for the super rich?
Fortunately this is untrue. Each
technology offers distinct advantages which make them
more suitable to certain applications at varying price
points.
Plasma screens are the most cost
effective way of achieving a very good quality 42”
picture from a display you can mount on the wall.
They provide superbly rich and vibrant colours and
smooth motion combined with good depth of field when
used with high quality sources. However the cheap
screens costing under a £ 1,800.00 are generally
worth avoiding as serious compromises to their picture
quality have been made to make them that price.
Ultimately LCD technology will overtake
plasma as it has numerous advantages. They last approximately
one third longer than plasmas, are lighter, produce
less heat and they do not suffer from screen burn
(this is a ghost image left on the screen by a static
image displayed on the screen for a long period of
time). However currently LCD screens are more expensive
than plasmas especially in larger sizes, but if you
want the best, a good LCD such as the Loewe Spheros
or Sharp will produce the best picture quality from
a wall mountable screen.
If you want a true home cinema room
then a DLP or LCD front projection unit is the best
option as they give by far the most cinematic image
available and provide a real cinema feel. A projector
is also the most cost effective way to achieve a big
screen image and for the same price as a good quality
42” plasma screen a good quality projector will
produce a seven foot wide image of superior quality
to a plasma screen!
A projector can be mounted invisibly
in the ceiling, but then descend at the push of a
button when you wish to watch a film, making it the
perfect compliment to a LCD or Plasma.
However it must be remembered that
projector will only give good results when viewed
in relatively darkened conditions and they are not
the best choice for every day television viewing.
Pros and Cons overview
| > Plasma |
|
Pros |
Cons |
> Best picture quality for the money (for
42” and above)
> Good for everyday use |
> Plasmas below £1800 are poor quality
> Shorter life than LCD (1/3 less)
> Can be lacking in features such as tuners
and memory card readers |
| > LCD |
|
Pros |
Cons |
> Better picture quality for
budgets over £4000 and screens below 42”
> Smaller LCDs are lighter and more versatile
> Features such as digital tuners and card
readers are standard
> Good for everyday use |
> More expensive
|
| > Projector |
|
Pros |
Cons |
> BBest
suited to dedicated cinema rooms
> Unrivalled image size
> Features such as digital tuners and card
readers are standard
> Projector and screen can be mounted invisibly,
descending at a button touch
|
> Image may be
too large for everyday viewing
|
|